Five Draft Predictions You Can Set Your Watch To
As April 25th approaches, more and more is becoming clear about the Draft. It is still too early to tell who will be selected when, but certain trends are developing. I personally would never be presumptuous enough to think that I can predict the exact order in which players will be taken in three weeks, but I am audacious enough to believe that I can not only identify those developing trends but go out on a limb and call them facts. It helps that no one can currently prove me wrong, but I’m sure this will be thrown in my face if any of these assertions are eventually found erroneous. I’m still willing to claim that you can take these “facts” to the bank.
1. No matter the order, Aaron Curry, Jason Smith and Eugene Monroe will be selected in the top four picks. Ok, this one is a little obvious, but let me start with a putt. If Matthew Stafford is taken first by Detroit, the next three picks will be the three stated above. The other possibility is that they are taken in succession with the top three picks and Seattle takes Michael Crabtree, Matthew Stafford or even Mark Sanchez whom Seattle is rumored to prefer over Stafford. Either way, Monroe, Smith and Curry are the safest players in the Draft and will be taken accordingly.
2. There will be no less than three OT’s selected in the top 10 picks. Out of the top 4 OT’s Eugene Monroe and Jason Smith are no brainers, but Andre Smith has character issues and scouts have questioned Michael Oher’s ability to be a franchise LT. There are simply, however, too many teams that need help at OT for this fact to be wrong. Detroit, St. Louis, Kansas City, Seattle, Cincinnati, San Francisco are all strong possibilities as landing spots for a LT this year. Michael Oher’s fantastic Pro Day vaulted him back into a conversation as a top 10 pick, and as for Andre Smith, Cincinnati doesn’t care about character and Mike Singletary won’t shy away from a teaching challenge. There is an outside chance that all four could be taken in the top 10, but that limb is still a little shaky to walk out on.
3. The latest Matthew Stafford will be selected is 8th. Detroit and Seattle are considered the most logical locations for Matthew Stafford, and Jacksonville is probably not looking for a QB, but Stafford will not make it past Jacksonville because they won’t be able to resist the top rated player at the position. Aaron Rodgers and Brady Quinn were both subject to the dread QB draft slide, but both of those players were the second QB selected in their respective years. Stafford played close to Jacksonville in the SEC so Jaguars scouts and fans are very familiar with the Georgia signal caller. Also, as I’ve stated before I think that Jack Del Rio is on the way out and new G.M. Gene Smith is planning for his and the team’s future. Don’t forget, David Garrard is Del Rio’s QB so as he goes, Gerrard goes.
4. At least one team that is slated to pick between 11 and 15 will trade down. All five teams have reasons to trade down and might have takers. Buffalo will benefit if a player with top 10 talent slips that the Bills aren’t interested and they would love to trade down so they can justifiably take TE Brandon Pettigrew who they love. Denver is the least likely, but they’ve already shown that they’re rebuilding and want to collect draft picks. Washington traded away their second and fourth round draft picks, while New Orleans has traded all of theirs away except their first, fourth and seventh round picks. The Texans are likely willing to move down, but Rick Smith would probably receive less than usual in return because he would be bidding against New Orleans who will be desperate to receive more picks.
5. Denver will not trade up to get a QB. Trading up to get a QB would completely undermine the reasoning that Pat Bowlen and Josh McDaniels used to deal disgruntled QB Jay Cutler to Chicago. The only way that Denver will come out of this deal not looking like they got duped is by rebuilding Mike Nolan’s defense. If they draft a QB, he will be constantly compared to Jay Cutler as was done with Aaron Rodgers and Brett Favre last year, but this would be a straight out of college rookie. I don’t even think that Denver would take Sanchez if he slipped to them at 12, but I’m not certain enough to call it fact because they haven’t shown the utmost intelligence since McDaniels took over. My guess is they’ll take front seven defensive players with both the 12th and 18th picks, especially because you it’s difficult to compare those players to a QB.
If you disagree with any of these claims, or have predictions of your own, feel free to tell me so in the comments. As the Draft gets even closer, more trends will become clear enough to me that I can continue to envision myself as a modern day football Nostradamus. Stay tuned.
1 recs |
8 comments
|
Comments
Prediction (dream)
Malcolm Jenkins will be wearing Steel Blue in 09.
"I'm just looking forward to something great happening in the city of Houston" - Tracy McGrady
Still waiting...
by DreKeem on Apr 6, 2009 8:47 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Rec'd, Good Article
Nice post TT. I agree with the general premise of nearly all of your statements, but disagree with a few points in the explanations.
1. In 95% of situations I would say you are right, but, it is possible that one of the tackles slips out of those top 4 if Detroit takes Stafford, the Rams take a tackle, Chiefs take Curry, and the Seahawks take either Sanchez or Crabtree. That would leave Monroe or Smith out in the cold, or at least to be drafted by Cleveland or Cinci.
2. Agree, completely. I doubt Oher will crack the top 10 in any way shape or form, his “instincts” are still considered too suspect by many scouts. Andre Smith will round out the tackles to 3 in the top 10 picks.
3. Yes, but, occasionally teams get QB shy in the first round and they end up falling far, even past teams that need one. Think Aaron Rogers 2006, or Brady Quinn in 2007. The top ranked QB is usually the exception to this, but there’s a first time for everything. I would still bet money you are right here.
4. Buffalo is as likely to reach for Pettigrew at pick 11 as trade down for him, I have little faith in that team. Good luck with TO btw!!
5. Denver will not trade up for Sanchez (or Stafford) but I still stick to the theory that it is a smart play for them to draft him if they fall to him. I’ve said it once I’ll say it a million times, the right time to draft a young QB is not when your team has none, but when they have a limited QB who can start but won’t be the future of your team….Chris Simms and Kyle Orton both fit in the category. None of us expect those guys to be starting for Denver in 3-5 years, so why wait to start training a guy who can fix your franchise?
Once again nice post.
"There was a pretty good group of free agent quarterbacks out there and, after studying them all, I liked the fact that he's young and I like the fact he's a mirror image of the guy we have (Matt Schaub) so when we're coaching Matt, we're coaching him, too." - Gary Kubiak on new Texans QB Dan Orlovsky
Matt Schaub = Safety Dan. We're in trouble.
by last texans fan on Apr 6, 2009 9:12 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Close,
but I disagree slightly on some points. I think Seattle will take a tackle, as Walter Jones is going to be out the door 2010 unless he restructures, but the possibility remains open. Jim Mora is a defense first coach, which makes me think he will go defense + running the football as his primary mentality, but stranger things have happened.
Change number 2 to the top 16 picks, and you have a deal. I forsee many possibilities where Smith/Oher get nabbed as the third tackle by San Diego, who desperately needs an RT. With both having issues (supposedly, but I would take Oher in a freaking heartbeat), they might slide with “safer” perceived talent available.
Concur with 3.
4. Absolutely concur. Hell I think Jacksonville will bill looking to trade down big time. After the whole Derrick Harvey thing, I bet they want to get out of the top 10 and still grab Darius Butler in the middle of the first. The rest all want to as well.
5. Agree as well. I really hope Josh McDaniels isn’t stupid enough to go and package his 2 first round picks to move up for a QB. If Sanchez is there at 12, they take him. However, for Denver to move up to 8, it would only cost them 1 third round pick along with their number 12 selection. If it only costs that, I say do it. Groom him behind Orton for a year or two, and then let him take over. This is Orton’s contract year anyways.
Here are some other, random guarantees I am willing to make.
6. Andy Reid will NOT take Knowshon Moreno, Beanie Wells, or Brandon Pettigrew with either of his first round picks. Why? Because he hates offensive talent, unless it’s an offensive lineman. Watch them go offensive tackle then defense with the first two picks. Eagles fans will cry themselves to sleep once again, and Donovan McNabb will find the bleach.
7. New England will have an amazing draft. Their needs are to fills aging defensive positions. If they walk away with Maualuga, Connor Barwin, Jarron Gilbert, and one of the second round SS ( Moore, Chung, etc ) in the first 2 rounds, I will cry. I wish the Texans managed to acquire 2 additional second round picks.
8. The Titans will NOT draft a first round receiver. Why? Because they hate offensive success, and for some reason don’t want to have anyone decent for Kerry Collins to throw to.
I might get bored and make some more.
by Riott on Apr 7, 2009 12:02 AM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Wow
I agree with all of them except for maybe six. The Andy Reed and Donovan McNabb were staring at the guillotine last year, so I wouldn’t be shocked if the they take one of those three you listed and an OL. Just my thinking.
Let's get the Texans a better fight song.
by Jake on Apr 7, 2009 6:39 AM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
No. 7 Ain't Fair
New England always has an awesome draft, every single year. Thats like saying “tonight it will be dark”. Does anyone really think that they went 11-5 because of Matt Cassel? Hah…hahahahahaha. I could throw to receivers like Randy Moss behind NE’s offensive line, the Patriots are practically a pro bowl team, and a big part of it is because every year they have more draft picks and spend them better than anyone else in the draft.
Your reasoning for each pick is that Reid is an idiot, the Patriots are geniuses, and the Titans are idiots. If you are going along that line you should throw in a dime about Al Davis’ Raiders and the Buffalo Bills trading their first round pick to Bill Parcells for Ricky Williams and a seventh round pick.
"There was a pretty good group of free agent quarterbacks out there and, after studying them all, I liked the fact that he's young and I like the fact he's a mirror image of the guy we have (Matt Schaub) so when we're coaching Matt, we're coaching him, too." - Gary Kubiak on new Texans QB Dan Orlovsky
Matt Schaub = Safety Dan. We're in trouble.
by last texans fan on Apr 7, 2009 11:38 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
Skill Positions
1. I’m gonna disagree w/ u on this. I’m thinking the top 4 picks are: Stafford, Smith, Monroe, and Crabtree in no particular order. Curry IS GOING TO DROP. lol, but probably to #5. There is no way a linebacker goes in the top 4, it hasn’t happenned in my lifetime, and I can’t see any of these teams drafting in the top 4 feeling they are going to be THAT much better w/ a versatile linebacker that hasn’t been taught to rush the passer. AJ Hawke was rated similar to Curry, yet he was taken #6, and while he is solid, he’s not a monster playmaker. Most interior linemen aren’t sack specialists, and the teams drafting in the top 4 don’t feel like that’s the splash they need to get better. I’m SURE KC thinks they are not far away from the playoffs considering they have a new head coach that just took his team to the superbowl, got a new stud qb, cutler’s out of their division, and San Diego scares noone right now, lol, and Oakland ppsssh. KC is drafting an OT or they are taking Crabtree: Bank on it. Curry is NOT their pick, I promise you.
2. Stafford is going to be #1. New coaches ALWAYS pick their qb their 1st year, either that or they have to say the incumbent QB is their guy (a la Jim Zorn). Schwartz has done neither, he says, “we need to explore options.” The FIRST option is ALWAYS Qb: Stafford is their guy.
3. Sanchez is going to be a top 12 pick. He will not slide past Denver, it’s not plausible. Denver has 2 mediocre qb’s in Simms and Orton and as mentioned by Riott that’s the best scenario to draft a qb and groom him w/o much pressure. Sanchez has talent, he’ll be gone by 12.
4. The Texans won’t have to trade down to get their man. Someone’s gonna fall that we like, as a matter of fact we may have a legitamite DECISION to make @ 15 b/w multiple guys that “we like.” Including: Michael Johnson, Malcolm Jenkins, Clay3, and Cushing. I’m banking on the idea that these 4 guys are going to be available where we pick.
5. New Orleans is trading this pick. Which is good for us cuz it may mean that a QB gets picked at 14, and that’s the premise of my #4. I can easily see NYJ moving up to nab their guy or someone else trading up to get 1 of the 2 rb’s or an OT. That’s a good thing for us b/c then we can get the defensive player of our choice. But trust me, NO is trading out of this pick.
lol, those are my 5 “guarantees.”
by wiseonekms on Apr 7, 2009 5:05 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Holy Crap
You write really well for an eight year old. Just kidding, Lavar Arrington was taken second overall in the year of our lord, 2000. Good logic to your arguments though, we’ll just have to wait and see who’s right. God I can’t wait for the draft.
Let's get the Texans a better fight song.
by Jake on Apr 7, 2009 5:33 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 























