Battle Red Blog: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Tobias Harris signs with Tennessee

"Fandom" Is Not Necessarily Defined As "Blind Faith"

As regular readers have no doubt seen, there's been an awful lot of debate at BRB the last few days about Brian Cushing. While the vehicle for the recent debate here has been Cushing, the argument is by no means limited to him. The issue is much larger. Namely, what does it mean to be a fan? Does criticizing a team or a player make someone less of a fan? Do "real fans" support every move their franchise or rooting interest makes? In my opinion, the answer to the two preceding questions is a resounding "NO."

Back on April 25th, I wrote this immediately after your Houston Texans made Brian Cushing the fifteenth player chosen in the 2009 NFL Draft:

Well, I hate this pick more than any other pick Smithiak has ever made. I hate it with the fire of a thousand suns. I hate life.

Vent as you see fit. I'm going to be catatonic until the second round.

In the weeks leading up to the draft, I made no secret that I wasn't a fan of Brian Cushing becoming a Texan. Upon Smithiak having the audacity to ignore the opinion of yours truly--a fan who does not have access to a fraction of the resources a NFL franchise does--and selecting Brian Cushing, I reiterated my disappointment with the decision in my typically understated manner. As I type this, I still wish the Texans had gone in a different direction with their first-round pick, and I say that as someone who has been grudgingly impressed with the positive reports about Cushing's professionalism, performance, and demeanor since he was drafted by Houston.

Does that failure to jump on the Cushing Bandwagon make me less of a fan of the Texans than, say, someone who has loved the Cushing pick from the very beginning? Absolutely not. Because here's the thing: I WANT TO BE WRONG, AND I WANT THE TEXANS TO SUCCEED. I honestly would love nothing more than for Cushing to garner All-Pro honors while playing for the Texans. I want him to be an anchor at LB in Houston for the next decade. I want him to be an integral part of the Texans winning multiple Super Bowls. I want to be able to look back on what I said/typed and remark, "Man, was I out of line. Let's call that Reason #4,378,294 why I'm not a general manager or coach in the NFL." That's fandom, and fandom does not have to equate with immediately embracing every move made by the organization.

Make no mistake about it: I'm going to root for Brian Cushing. Because he's a Texan, and I root for the Texans. Given the choice between Cushing proving that I'm (more of) a moron and having some sort of satisfaction that my grossly amateur personnel evaluation was spot on, I'll take the dunce cap every day of the week and twice on Sundays. I am, however, going to bitch and moan if and/or when Cushing doesn't play well. This does not mean that I'm rooting for him to be a bust; I'm liable to bitch and moan about nearly every Texan not named Andre Johnson or Mario Williams at some point during a season.

Yet there appears to be a school of thought out there that says I shouldn't utter a derogatory word about any Texan. That as fans of the Houston Texans, it's our job to pump sunshine and good cheer about all players at all times. Why? Why would I forfeit my right to complain or criticize once a player becomes a Texan? For anyone out there who's thinking, "You forfeit that right as long as the player is wearing steel blue, liberty white, and battle red," I would ask if you followed that golden rule the entire time David Carr was under center for the Texans. I'm guessing very few people outside of Zoolander's immediate family can respond in the affirmative to that question.

And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. As a fan, you have the right to opine, even negatively, without it making you any less of a diehard. Because in the final analysis, we all want the same thing: For the Houston Texans to win as many games as possible.

Thoughts on the matter? Let it fly in the Comments below.

6 recs  |  Comment 39 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Tim's post FTMFW

Well thought out, and well written Tim.

So you're saying that now I have to think of some witty Sig that will be applicable across all the SBN sites? Go TexanHornStroKets!

by Shake on Aug 14, 2009 5:06 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Thanks, Shake

Looking forward to a day when being a Texans fan doesn't mean that April is the highlight of my season...

by Tim on Aug 14, 2009 5:35 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions   0 recs

Thank you for blindly rooting for Brian Cushing...
Make no mistake about it: I’m going to root for Brian Cushing. Because he’s a Texan, and I root for the Texans.

That is all I read, but I agree whole-heartedly!

It will happen

by Rip Jersey on Aug 14, 2009 5:13 PM CDT reply actions   1 recs

Tim I'm with you

I don’t have to agree with anything the org does and I can still root for them, in fact as a Broncos fan also I have had to choke that down alot this off season.
That said my biggest issue with the last couple of days is the personal attacks, it just seems a little childish, I’m much more interested in the though provoking banker than personal one ups man ship. Not saying I want Love, flowers, and smiles all the time, just respectful discussions.

by Texans-Brocos on Aug 14, 2009 5:29 PM CDT reply actions   1 recs

Well said, Tim

Blind faith as a fan is a sign of myopia I hope to never have.

David Carr is a great example (along with Petey Faggins). Were we supposed to just keep blindly watching him turtle at every opportunity? Then, when we released him, off-handedly say, “Oh, his play has sucked for a couple of years and I haven’t liked him.”

It’s intellectually dishonesty at its peak.

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 14, 2009 5:48 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Exactly, a fan should be able to question what the FO does.

And then now I will say exactly what you said…….“fan should still root for the team”

by Schlauton on Aug 14, 2009 6:11 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

It seems to me...

That Cushing has brought out the very best in you! You care so much about him that you put together a wonderful, thoughtful post based around him. I knew you liked him all along. It was only a matter of time.

"I'm just looking forward to something great happening in the city of Houston" - Tracy McGrady

Still waiting...

by DreKeem on Aug 14, 2009 7:00 PM CDT reply actions   1 recs

Great Post

I think the best quote is:

“Because here’s the thing: I WANT TO BE WRONG, AND I WANT THE TEXANS TO SUCCEED. I honestly would love nothing more than for Cushing to garner All-Pro honors while playing for the Texans … I want to be able to look back on what I said/typed and remark, “Man, was I out of line. Let’s call that Reason #4,378,294 why I’m not a general manager or coach in the NFL.” That’s fandom"

Exactly. A fan is someone who will criticize the team’s move/players, but want to be wrong about it. The only time it goes too far, I’d guess, is when people who follow the team indulge in a bunch of self-congratulating “I told you so’s” if their criticism turns out to be spot on. If they follow Tim’s approach, they are definitely a real fan.

by killtacular on Aug 14, 2009 7:41 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

What's Love?

Well written. I’m of the school that blind unquestioning faith is less love than daring to challenge your team/organization/whatever it is to do better and knowing that they can rise up and outshine what you expected of them.

A bit soppy maybe, but are we just going to let our kids be lazy bums and accept them “as is”? I think not – likewise for our teams.

BTW I hated the Cushing pick too, but I’m excited to see what he can do. :)

by Tris X P on Aug 14, 2009 8:33 PM CDT reply actions   2 recs

rec'ed

Well said and welcome!

We almost named our son Tristram after a certain baseball HOFer.

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 14, 2009 8:42 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

well done Timmy!

Some of sports most passionate fans bitch about their team, but stand behind them through wins and losses. A" true " fan has every right to piss and moan as well as scream and cheer for thier team. I loved David Carr and then hated David Carr, but I always wanted him to succeed.

p.s. I hope the whole Timmy thing wasn’t offensive.

GO TEXANS!!!!

This is the year.......

by Texanmaniac on Aug 14, 2009 8:42 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Timmy

Is offensive to him. It’s spelled: Timmeh.

I slay me.

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 14, 2009 8:43 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Not Offensive At All

I went by “Timmy” through much of my youth, and I still get called it regularly by several buddies and my wife.

Or I would, if bloggers had wives. Or girlfriends. Or females in their lives of any sort that weren’t a devastating combination of landlord and mother.

Looking forward to a day when being a Texans fan doesn't mean that April is the highlight of my season...

by Tim on Aug 14, 2009 10:48 PM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

I've always thought

Constructive criticism is a great way to show love. We invest a lot of ourselves, and our Sundays, in the Texans, it’d be foolish to have blind faith.

by JimboTexan on Aug 14, 2009 9:50 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I'm a fan. Tim is a fan. Those of us who criticize - even harshly - are fans.

People who never question anything and just pump sunshine – those people are called cheerleaders. They usually come equipped with short shorts, boobies, and pom poms.

by HoustonDiehards on Aug 15, 2009 12:27 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Brillant insight, Chris.

To quote Meat Loaf: “You Took The Words Right Outta My Mouth.”

BattleRedBlog.com DontMessWithTexans.com
Clutchfans.net - Chuck 4 TexansTalk.com - Frak The Jags
Twitter - Zepp1978 Facebook - Zepp1978

by Mike Kerns on Aug 15, 2009 1:18 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Well Said

I haven’t fallen in love with your comments regarding BC when he was drafted, but it seems you’re coming around

There is a difference between bashing and criticism, and we as fans needs to respect that, as far as i’m concerned

We don’t have to all be starstruck by particular decisions and players, but as fans I think we need to at least provide the benefit of the doubt

When brian cushing is concerned, I’ll admit – It wouldn’t surprised me if he’s ever taken steroids in his life… but it wouldn’t surprise me if he hasn’t either… For the time being, he’s our Strongside Outside Linebacker, and i’ll go to bat for him any day of the week until he gives me a reason not to… There’s not enough Texan fans out there to do otherwise

by TheKid87 on Aug 15, 2009 1:52 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Not a big fan of Jacoby Jones . . .

And a little part of me dies each time he fumbles a punt. It’s as if JJ couldn’t give a nutra-rat-shit about protecting the football, but in this instance Kubiak is the real meatpipe strangler for continuing to send his butterfingered ass out on the field. Enough is fucking enough.

by carsonwayne on Aug 15, 2009 4:30 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

You wrote some nice things

But, I haven’t noticed a school of thought that says you can’t say a bad thing about any Texan. I have noticed everyone saying just about anything they want and discussion about it. I have seen a school of thought basically agreeing with the derogatory things that people have posted. There is very little dissension it seems. Some posters say a lot of bad things and the school of thought seems to agree and other posters rarely say a bad thing and the school of thought still agrees. It seems when there is a dissenting comment about a derogatory statement from a poster; that is when the school of thought turns against the commenter. Is that the point of your post? Am I the only one who has noticed that?

It will happen

by Rip Jersey on Aug 15, 2009 4:57 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

The Problem Is

We are launching into another bout of player flagellation, à la Mario (but without quite as much vehemance). Cushing is being taken to task for reasons of innuendo and guessing, not necessarily performance. If all you knew about Cushing was what you read on BRB, you’d think that he was an overdrafted oft-injured steroid freak with a ponytail. Even his strict training and nutrition regimens are somehow spun as a negative.


All I would suggest is, take him to task for his performance, and not what is gossip. These guys are human, and they know what people say about them. Look at Mario. We made him miserable for over a year because the Texans didn’t take a couple of other players. And it turned out that we were almost all wrong.


So is Cushing a steroid freak? Four years of testing says, “no.” Does Cushing have an injury problem? What measure indicates an injury problem? He started 3 1/3 seasons, and played a significant role before that. He had two injuries,resulting in missing parts of two seasons. Is that unreasonable, considering how many games he started/played in?

by kozanack on Aug 15, 2009 6:53 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

good points

Partly, we have no performance data points to work with, which isn’t helping. Warm training camp fuzzies do not count. And I haven’t seen anybody spin is training and nutrition habits negatively.

With my enumerated list of issues of him BEFORE he was drafted, he’s done nothing to dispel them.

If he gets out on the field and kicks ass, great. The coaching staff is investing a ton of faith in him because of his importance in the new defensive scheme, and I hope he can fill that role.

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 15, 2009 7:43 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Oh yeah

I was one of the first on the Mario bandwagon, so I’m safe there :-)

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 15, 2009 7:44 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

If you're first.

I guess I was second. Never rooted for teh Bush and VY(I did when he was playing UT) to be drafted by the Texans. But it’s because I always put more emphasis on a teams defense rather than the offense.

by Jordann on Aug 18, 2009 4:29 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I Think A Mid-First Rd Draft Pick Is In A Tough Spot

It’s hard to get excited about them. The fans have high hopes, but at selection #15 the game changers are all gone. Too early to take a project with big potential, and to early to find those overlooked guys. If he performs as expected, he’ll be a 5-10 year starter with a Pro Bowl or two.

by kozanack on Aug 15, 2009 11:36 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

x
If he performs as expected, he’ll be a 5-10 year starter with a Pro Bowl or two.

That would be awesome.

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 15, 2009 11:38 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I grew up on the wrong side of the tracks

So i sympathize with the guy. When my wife took me to meet her parents, their reaction was kind of like, “he’s not what we hoped for, but we really can’t complain….”

by kozanack on Aug 15, 2009 11:44 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

heh

My mother in law is an LCSW, so, yeahhhhhh, she does complain. HAHA!

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 15, 2009 11:48 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

last time..

I got excited about a mid first rd pick was with a guy that sported a bad-ass tribal half-sleeve.
Turns out that was the best thing about him.

by Jordann on Aug 18, 2009 4:30 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Also

When I get shit wrong, I’m not afraid to admit it.

Note to self: Insert something witty here.

by bigfatdrunk on Aug 15, 2009 7:52 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

good stuff

In your defense, CBs can be very difficult to project.

While, on the other hand, Mario was the only choice the Texans ever really had.

Vince Young is a shot-putter, and Reggie Bush… in this scheme?… as the #1 pick?… =D

there is no "I" in "team"...but there is a "me"

by Cut Block on Aug 16, 2009 11:12 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Well

You were wrong to post your post in the first place. Haven’t heard any apologies. And before you ask, “what was a wrong about?”, you were wrong for all the reasons that kozanack just stated. And, besides that, posting what you posted just to prove that you can post it, is not a good reason.

It will happen

by Rip Jersey on Aug 22, 2009 6:38 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

I believe in team concept

I think it would be pretty foolish to cheer for my team blindly and not question some of the moves. I also feel as though you should welcome in all players and root for them though. I wasn’t a huge fan of the Cushing pick but I want to see the guy do well now that he is a Texan. I hate the guys that constantly bring up who we should have picked… that is annoying! Woulda, coulda, shoulda! We woulda, coulda, shoulda made the playoffs last year if we didn’t have fumblitis, poor coaching in the red zone, and injuries. Sometimes as fans I think we bitch too much about what we wish would have happened and don’t enjoy what is actually happening. The Texans are an improved club and this year should be a fun year to watch, Go Texans!

by wasteph on Aug 15, 2009 7:04 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

We would have won the division last year, if we had gone 16-0.

Seriously.

there is no "I" in "team"...but there is a "me"

by Cut Block on Aug 16, 2009 11:13 AM CDT up reply actions   1 recs

Don't want to sound like a sucking up kiss-ass, but I completely agree with you Tim

A) Only true fans criticize. As Chris stated only bandwagoneers and cheerleaders never utter a discouraging word. The day one stops analyzing and/or criticizing both management decisions and player performance, is the day one stops being a fan.

B) I too hated the Cushing pick, but as kozanack pointed out, it was mainly because of suspected steroid use and the ramifications thereof. Several times before the draft I described Cushing as a career-ending leg injury waiting to happen. Like Tim, however, once the pick was made and he donned the steel-blue jersey, I started hoping like hell that I was wrong, and Smithiak would once again prove they are genius(es).

C) I think the coaching staff is being justafiably cautious with Cushing, and the issue is being blown way out of proportion by the media and the bloggers. I realize that is partly wishful thinking, but (see B) I want Cushing to be a smashing success. If Cushing plays as well as Smithiak believes, our chances of having nail-biting games in December goes way up.

Looking forward to the game tonight. Want to get a look at all of the new guys, and just enjoy some Texans football once again like a true fan. GO TEXANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It took the Astros 44 years to get to the Series, the Oilers-Texans are due to get to the big dance...Go Texans!!!!!

by oiler-texan diehard on Aug 15, 2009 12:00 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Agreed

While I like the Cushing pick, I felt that way about the Travis Johnson pick when it happened (desperately wanted Derrick Johnson), the Duane Brown pick (wanted Jenkins), the Mario Williams pick (wanted VY, but LOVE him now!), and Amobe Okoye (wanted Alan Branch… ouch!). At the time I loved the Carr pick (ouch), Dre, and Donta too. I was in between with the Babin trade up, and we know how that turned out.

If you cut me open I bleed Texan Battle Red/Deep Steel Blue/Liberty White, but I do not just drink the kool-aid when it comes to management decisions (draft picks, play calling, etc…).

by thanos023 on Aug 15, 2009 3:56 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

rec'd

One cannot have an investment in something, without the ability to be critical of it.

there is no "I" in "team"...but there is a "me"

by Cut Block on Aug 16, 2009 11:06 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Rec'd

Well said Tim.
Bravo.

We invest so much into the Texans(or any other sports teams that we root for) and it would be ridiculous if our right to criticize our beloved franchise(s) was taken away.

by Jordann on Aug 18, 2009 4:34 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Your home for analysis and rants about all things Houston Texan.
Start posting about the Texans »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

The_catch_small
The Real Reason Tennessee has won 3 in a row...
Small
BESF Halloween
Receiverchart_small
"You stay classy, Bud Adams"
New_ar15_small
Veterans Day
Animal_chin_small
Glossary of Battle Red Blog Terms

Recent FanPosts

Car-mario-stop-1024_small
One last Texans bedroom poll
10865_1264495206215_1044784186_841568_1224909_n_small
Bartering
Small
Why not spread the field more?
Small
What positions should the Texans focus on in the draft?
Cuntler_small
If I where coach (and I'm sure everyone is glad I'm not)
Mc_small
Ask Music City Miracles
Texans_small
Arian Foster promoted to 53 man roster
Stars_moons_planets_small
Cushing Maintains Top Spot on the Rookie-Meter During Bye
Images_small
Arian Foster was justed moved to the Active Roster!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation


Editor

Brb_small Tim

Managers

Receiverchart_small bigfatdrunk

Funny_kubiak_small Jake

Authors

Comic_zombies_attack_circa_1999_small Riott

Sunaipa_small Mike Kerns

Pimp_small DreKeem