High Five: What Is The Best Transaction In Texans History?
We had our corresponding poll of awfulness, but now, with Tim showing us the optimism that we will surely come into the season with before the Texans ruin our dreams again the glorious 16-0 season we are about to embark on, it's time to check out the opposite side of things. The best transactions in Texans history have mostly been simple affairs. Only one trade makes the list, although there were opportunities for a few others to go up there. Notably, we might need to revisit the Joe Flacco - Duane Brown/Steve Slaton/Dominique Barber and Ben Tate deal(s) sometime down the line.
For now, lets focus on this glorious poll. It's like choosing which child is your favorite, except you have to do it.
Drafting Andre Johnson with the #3 Overall Pick in the 2003 NFL Draft.
Blind squirrel, meet acorn. Charlie Casserly didn't provide much to the City of Houston over his years of putting together 3-4 defenses with no nose tackle and offenses with no quarterback, but he did stumble upon one of the best receivers of the 2000s with the #3 overall pick. Of course, he probably would've picked Charles Rogers over Andre Johnson given the chance, but let's not drive ourselves to more drinking with that thought. Instead, let's have a laugh!
SING IT!
Drafting Mario Williams with the #1 Overall Pick in the 2006 NFL Draft.
Legend has it that if you say Casserly was responsible for this pick, MDC will douse your house with a gasoline fire hose and then light it on fire.
The degree of difficulty was monumental. The Texans were faced with a choice between Heisman trophy winner Reggie Bush--national media darling, and University of Texas quarterback Vince Young--Texas media darling. Instead, they went off the board with some no-name defensive end from North Carolina State, becoming a national joke and drawing the ire of most of the fanbase, every Texas sports writer, and most ESPN pundits as well.
After a stalled first year, the Texans have clearly come out of it with the better player. Bush may have a Super Bowl ring, but he's just a part-time player. Young has swagger, and Just. Wins. Games, (TM) But he also has given the state of Tennessee what it rightfully deserves a lot of drama, a lot of questions, and thus far, not much in terms of actual passing yards. All Williams has done is notched 39.5 sacks in four years, despite a poor first year and playing most of last year with one arm, changing every national writer's opinion on the pick aside from perhaps Richard Justice. I'd say that worked out pretty well.
Drafting DeMeco Ryans with the #33 Overall Pick in the 2006 NFL Draft.
As great as those first two picks were, they were Top 3 picks. If you can't evaluate the top of the draft, you're destined to screw up. But to get a two-time Pro Bowler who is an incredible force in the community, a valued team leader, and one of the best middle linebackers in football at #33 overall? Now that's a pick. All DeMeco has done in his time with the Texans is rack up 404 tackles, 7.5 sacks, 6 forced fumbles, and 2 interceptions while being the absolute heart of the defense. He gets additional bonus points for being benevolent with MDC when he discovered his name being blatantly ripped off in the title of a certain football blog that used to exist.
Trading the #8 Overall Pick in the 2007 NFL Draft (Jamaal Anderson), the #39 Overall Pick in the 2007 NFL Draft (Justin Blalock) and the #48 Overall Pick in the 2008 NFL Draft (Fred Davis) for the #10 Overall Pick in the 2007 NFL Draft (Amobi Okoye) and Matt Schaub.
Look, you can juggle the picks anyway you want to and make this trade look bad from a talent perspective. The Texans could have picked Darrelle Revis in the 2007 first, Ryan Kalil in the 2007 second, and Ray Rice in the 2008 second. But this team needed a quarterback badly, and even though they overpaid a bit in pick value, I don't think any real Texans fan would go back in time and alter this deal. Schaub has vanquished our memories of David Carr en route to throwing for 4,700 yards last year, and in all probability, will be the quarterback when the Texans make their first playoff appearance in team history sometime in the near future.
Oh, and Okoye might be the second-best player in that trade too. That's just gravy.
Drafting Brian Cushing with the #15 Overall Pick in the 2009 NFL Draft.
Steroids, steroids, steroids. Suspension. HCG. HEB. Whatever ugly words you use to follow up Brian Cushing's first year as a Texan, you can't ignore the dramatic impact he had on the field from the moment he set foot on it. I was one of the many that wanted Clay Matthews over him, but he showed his worth and proved Rick Smith and Gary Kubiak right with his outrageous double Rookie Of The Year campaign. He showed that not only could he tackle, but he could rush the quarterback and defend all non-Dallas Clark receivers fairly well. That versatility helped catapult the Texans defense, one of the worst in football for the past five years, all the way up to the border of average and mediocre. Another first round homer for Smith and Kubiak, exempting the steroid hoopla we've had to deal with the last couple of months.
Just missed: Flacco-Brown/Slaton trade, getting an extra third rounder by stashing Drew Henson, Charlie Rogers for Jay Foreman, signing Kevin Walter in the 2006 offseason, Dunta Robinson in 2005 (he turned out bad, but was great pre-injury), Eric Winston in 2006, Owen Daniels in 2006, various versions of "Getting rid of (Player X)."
So what do you say BRB? Are you mad I left out the Samkon Gado for Vernand Morency trade? Go ahead, play favorites. It'll be fun.
1 recs |
34 comments
|
Comments
Went With The Schaub Deal
Because I think that involved a bit more genius than Casserly simply taking whichever WR Matt Millen didn’t.
Ballsiest move? Definitely taking Super Mario first overall.
Looking forward to a day when being a Texans fan doesn't mean that April is the highlight of my season...
I went Schaub for one reason
Andre is the the closest thing we have to a hall of fame caliber player. Without getting Schaub he would have kept on getting his good numbers despite a poor QB and and a bad team while never making it off of all the “best players you’ve never seen” list. Sure we could have gotten another QB, but who knows how that turns out. Quite simply, if Schaub doesn’t come in and start making enough plays to let AJ show his full potential then we are probably sitting around crying in our bleach watching AJ catch passes for another team.
Mario took the biggest balls because we didn’t follow conventional wisdom (and some of you were pissed about it….even if you don’t admit it now). The Mario pick might have led to the most criticism in the media, but the Schaub trade was riskier if you think about it.
"Well, at least our players kept their helmets on, so that showed some intelligence"-Bob McNair
I'm with team Mario.
Think about how different this franchise would be if we traded a dominant pass rusher for a bad running back, or ALTERNATELY, how this franchise would look if we had an unproven Vince Young trying to make things work in Year 5.
- Rivers McCown, From Mom's Basement | Twitter | SB Nation Houston | Battle Red Blog
I thought about that too
I don’t think Vince was ever really an option for us. If we didn’t have Mario we would be a team with a bad defense with one of the best passing games in the league who have to hope they can outscore you and hang on to win…wait, that sounds familiar.That’s basically what we were last year.
That’s not a knock on Mario at all. I don’t think he gets enough credit, but he couldn’t transform the defense all by himself because he simply hasn’t had enough help(even with Meco and Cush). I would rather have him than not because I think the defense is a piece or two away (and maybe a little scheme tweak).
"Well, at least our players kept their helmets on, so that showed some intelligence"-Bob McNair
I went with the Schaub deal
That’s a lot of picks to invest in a QB, but Schaub’s been worth every one of those picks and the huge contract he got after.
"Lord, beer me strength."
What about?
Picking up Pollard from waivers? It is very unusual to get a player of that caliber on waivers.
What about dumping David Carr? He had to go!
This poll needed an OTHER.
I suppose if all of the stars, moons and planets align it could be possible, but what are the chances of that?
by Rip Jersey on Jul 22, 2010 10:39 AM CDT via mobile reply actions 1 recs
Can I just say
All of the options are good but not great moves.
Pollard off the Street That is the best move EVER!!
You can't fix Dumb or being a VYFB
For what you have listed...
I would have to say Schaub because we instantly improved our passing game and made all of our receiving options better with Matt on the field vs. David.
However, for a FA pick-up, I would have to go with Bernard Pollard because one of our weakest positions increased overnight and it didn’t cost us any draft picks or players to do so!
"I just want Texas to be number one in something other than executions, toll roads and property taxes." ~ Kinky Friedman
IN ORDER OF IMPACT/ACUITY
I would have to say Mario first because that ballsy moved saved us from picking Bush and delaying the slow rise to respectability that we are now at. Not Mario in himself obviously, but the avoidance of taking the easier worse choices.
Second would be the Schaub, he is a top 5 quarterback.
A.J. – he is not #1 because he fell into our laps. There was no astuteness there other than not overthinking and picking a lesser player once Rogers was gone.
Pollard – I am ready to run through a brick wall now that this guy is onboard. A whole new attitude for our D. To paraphrase, Per Pollard, we have involved from the hope to win gang, to the expect to win bad muthfu….shut your mouth…head hunting, f the fine, bad mamba jamba team that we all have prayed for years. I am so excited.
meaningful football games in '08...MAKE THAT 09
fix
involved = evolved.
meaningful football games in '08...MAKE THAT 09
Mario
For brio, and the unending gift that is Young/Bush schadenfraude.
nah
I vote for “Andre Johnson kicking Phillip Buchanon’s ass in the locker room at halftime during the Kansas City Chiefs game in November 2005”. I mean, someone had to hit P-Buch hard enough to put him on the IR – because he sure shied away from contact in that game!
and that has to qualify as a “transaction” right?
The Pollard contingent is pretty strong here.
Look, I love the guy, but he’s not in the same class as any of these other players yet. He didn’t even play a full season, and you can’t give him extra credit for how the Texans have traditionally sucked balls at safety.
Probably a deserving add to the honorable mentions though.
- Rivers McCown, From Mom's Basement | Twitter | SB Nation Houston | Battle Red Blog
by riversmccown on Jul 22, 2010 2:31 PM CDT reply actions 1 recs
Agreed On All Counts
Looking forward to a day when being a Texans fan doesn't mean that April is the highlight of my season...
by Tim on Jul 22, 2010 3:18 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
^^Haters
BP will take his respect if you won’t give it to him and knock the piss outta you.
hCG levels within acceptable range.
Re: Pollard
Any GM can make a draft pick. Where’s the wonderment of that? Whoa! A first-rounder worked out! Whoopie! Your criteria was best transaction, not best player. Making a good draft pick does not warrant any special praise. Out of your choices, the Mat Scaub trade is a difference maker. But the Pollard waiver pick-up worked out beyond expectations, cost nothing and provided a big difference on the field and in the locker room. I vote OTHER, as in Pollard….
I suppose if all of the stars, moons and planets align it could be possible, but what are the chances of that?
by Rip Jersey on Jul 22, 2010 5:06 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
Sounds cathartic
I’m in!
- Rivers McCown, From Mom's Basement | Twitter | SB Nation Houston | Battle Red Blog
by riversmccown on Jul 23, 2010 7:14 AM CDT up reply actions
THE HOUSTON TEXANS BLOW!
ok.. my subject was to catch yall’s attention. i love the texans. biggest fan ever! now, Pollard was a great move he is a good safety and a great leader. i think his attitude will immensly improve our defense i think it will make everyone more physical and wanna follow his lead so to speak, but since someone on the comments came up with that,
ok.. my subject was to catch yall’s attention. i love the texans. biggest fan ever! now, Pollard was a great move he is a good safety and a great leader. i think his attitude will immensly improve our defense i think it will make everyone more physical and wanna follow his lead so to speak, but since someone on the comments came up with that,back to schaub, that was definitely the best pick. yes andre johnson is the man and might be the best receiver in the NFL, BUT, without schaub we would be shit. our offensive production immediately improved by leaps and bounds after we had schaub under center.
by houstonduckhunter on Jul 22, 2010 3:01 PM CDT reply actions
Captain Meco
I said it when he was drafted. None of the other pieces on the defense work nearly as well without him.
Why isn’t the Bernard Pollard pickup included in this poll?
hCG levels within acceptable range.
Matt Schaub
It’s all about positional value. If you don’t have a quarterback, you will never win. If you have a great quarterback, then you can start building around him. An All-Universe wide receiver catching for him and Mario rushing other passers certainly makes him better, but it all keys around the quarterback.
The strong do what they have to do; the weak accept what they have to accept
Oh, and if we had an other...
Cutting Petty Faggins.
The strong do what they have to do; the weak accept what they have to accept
Without Question
QB is the most important position in the entire organization. Schaub was worth two 1st round picks.
It's Our Time.... or something...
by bennprince on Jul 22, 2010 6:21 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
I went with Meco simply because he lasted to #33
meaning we spent less on him than any of the other 4 players and he paid HUGE dividends. He is one awesome MLB and defensive leader. Check out the list of players taken before him. Some real stars in that 1st round. Emphasizes what an inexact art is drafting and how fortunate we were that all those other GM’s whiffed on Meco.
Using that same logic would put the Pollard acquisition in the same class because he cost us nothing.
It took the Astros 44 years to get to the Series, the Oilers-Texans are due to get to the big dance...Go Texans!!!!!
by oiler-texan diehard on Jul 22, 2010 8:27 PM CDT reply actions
I went with Cushing
Because Cushing is the best player who has ever played on this defense.
I picked schaubb
mostly because though he is a borin interview, he brought the texans o out of the dark ages!!! Johnson was kind of happenstance. And was an amazing steal but schaub’s deal just made my life.
"Your mother is a hamster and your father smells of elderberries! Now Go away or I shall taunt you a second time!"
Go Texans!
Other: ○ Tony Boselli
Although horribly wrong in reality, taking Boselli as our first ever choice thrilled me to pieces. I thought, perhaps unconsciously, that the selection an OT rather than some pretty QB or RB or WR gave an impression of toughness right from the beginning.
Houston Texans Number One
Schaub
Get yourself a QB that’s highly intelligent, a great leader, a film-room junkie, and getting to sit behind an overrated passer/dog-killer itching for a chance and set up the move to get a DT and WR with mountains of potential (Jakespeare was in this mix too, right? 3rd round pick that might not have been made if we didn’t get rid of the 2nd). Rick, you are a gentleman and a scholar.
…ok, random use of pictures, but I did a version of this where I mention this guy, and I didn’t wanna get rid of him.

We miss you, Marvin!!!
Schaub..
week 2 against the Panthers in 2007, when the team came from 14-0. Matt threw a long TD to Andre I remember thinking the team looked different. The pick of the best WR in the solar system, before he was, was big, but like someone mentioned earlier, I think was just a case of picking who Detroit didn’t.
GO TEXANS!!!!
Our time will come...

























